The Nocturnal Rogue: Adventuring with Tarte’s Rainforest After Dark Eye and Cheek Palette!

Greetings from the deafening jungle night, fellow rogues!

As you might imagine, we rogues spend quite a bit of our time in the dark. Calling this the ‘nocturnal rogue’ might seem like stating the obvious, but I couldn’t resist when I set out to write up my review of the Tarte Rainforest After Dark palette, and a recent adventure made it particularly appropriate!

Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

The adventuring party approaches the artefact, excitement and trepidation as thick as the jungle humidity…

I have to admit, Tarte’s really been hitting it out of the park for me, packaging -wise recently. First there was the MATTEnificent palette’s glorious purple geode. Then, I saw the adventure posting for a mysterious wooden artifact, inlaid with a golden, jewelled snake. The jewel was even reputed to be purple, and the artefact to contain glittering purple and golden magic! Well, I mean, I couldn’t tear that adventure posting off the tavern board fast enough, could I? I rounded up as many members of the adventuring party as were willing to go chasing for it, and off we set for the rainforest! Jungle temples are something we don’t usually get to raid, so everyone was quite excited. Even Khael the wizard, whose last experience with artefacts related to purple and venomous things turned out rather differently than he expected, was puffing away eagerly at his pipe.

Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

And lo, the treasure was laid bare. Always send the rogue in first, people. Checking for traps and all that…

By the time we’d hacked our way through the undergrowth, dodged or disarmed all the dart traps and arrived in the treasure chamber, everyone was champing at the bit to get that thing open! Fortunately, I managed to convince them to let the rogue go first, just in case there were any booby traps. Aside from a clear plastic sheet with the shade names on it and a card with a couple of look ideas (not pictured) however, there were no final barriers between adventurers and treasure! The wooden (veneer on plastic ;-)) artefact contains a gloriously large mirror,  6 pans of eyeshadow, and one each of blush, bronzer and highlighter. I was particularly looking forward to the latter two, as this is the first bronzer I’ve ever owned, and the first powder highlighter too (the only other one I have being a tiny sample of Benefit’s High Beam).

Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

Pretty… 😀 Also: no dart traps! Yay!

Let’s dive straight in, shall we? Appropriate to the ‘fall’ (it’s Autumn, people!) season that this is released for, the eyeshadows run along generally cool, purply lines. There’s a mixture of mattes, sparkly satins and metallics, and the shades cover both ‘useful’ and ‘OOH’ areas of the eyeshadow spectrum. General notes: I found most of them to be soft and very blendable, with an adequate wear time (no primer!) of around 8 hours (although eyeshadows don’t tend to migrate too much on me). The names, like those in the MATTEnificent palette, take a leaf from OPI’s book of groan-worthy half-puns, although I tend to find that these make me smile more than roll my eyes. 😉 In terms of specifics:

Bare To Explore is a matte, light pinkish/tan ‘medium skin’ colour. It’s the ‘base’ colour, essentially, although I found that if I used it as an all- over wash and then attempted to put other similar light colours over the top, it muddied them a little bit. It was great for browbone-edge-of-colours blending though, or as a crease shade (for those of us who are very pale!), when you have something like, say, UD Sin over the rest of your lid.

Make A Mauve is, well, mauve! It’s a satin eyeshadow with a sprinkling of fine golden sparkle, and is probably one of my favourites in the palette!

Plum Away With Me is a brown-undertoned plum satin, with excellent pigmentation. It’s worth noting that this shade in particular (along with Make a Mauve), are rather perfect bruise colours for the vampirically pale among us.  I say this not as a deterrent, as they are gorgeous, but you do have to be a little bit careful, as the Plum in particular packs a  bruisy colour punch (BA-dum TISH!) if you’re not!

Up to No Gold is a pigmented, smooth, metallic gold. It’s not too yellow, it’s not too white. In other words, it’s excellent, and goes so beautifully with the purples here.

The matte, camel colured Tan-gled Up in You is probably the worst shade in the palette for me. Having said that, it’s not *bad*, it was just the stiffest/driest shade, and perhaps the least exciting or useful for me in terms of colour. I found it to be a decent crease shade.

Don’t Turn A-Brown is a cool, dark brown matte. There’s not too much I can say for this one, as dark browns don’t really need much of an introduction. They’re brown. You can use ’em as a liner, you can use ’em for a smokey eye, you can use ’em for your eyebrows if the colour’s right! 😀

Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

Eyeshadow swatches!

Next up are the cheek products! Here things get a bit harder to explain for me (at this point anyway) as I’m not really used to either bronzer or highlighter! I’ll be experimenting more with these as time goes by, so updates may be forthcoming! In purely technical terms, though, I can definitely give you the scoop 😉  

Unleashed is a nice, slightly beige-based light pink blush. I say beige-based because (as you can see in my unblended swatch), the pinkness of it doesn’t stand out as much as you might expect on my vampire skin. It’s quite a nice, natural flush kind of colour, and I found it to blend easily enough and last the whole day. The only thing you might say against it is typical of my experience with Tarte blushes, which is that you have to rub a bit at the surface of the new blush to get the colour going, as it feels quite hard and smooth to start. After that though, you’re fine!

Park Ave Princess is probably the best I could have hoped for in terms of a ‘comes in a palette’ bronzer. It’s not extremely dark (which is a pro for me, but may be a ‘meh’ for darker skinned rogues), and not extremely orange, and it doesn’t have any glitter or shimmer. I’m in the process of trying to find ways to use this, but I’m still quite chuffed about owning my first bronzer anyway. I did read that the colour is different to that of other Park Ave Princesses that Tarte has released. 😉

Champagne is a VERY SHIMMERY pale gold highlighter. Highlighters are another thing that are a bit of a mystery to me. Because I already glow in the dark, I don’t tend to feel like I need one, but I do like some sparkle in my life. This highlighter blends out nicely enough, and doesn’t make you look like an absolute disco ball, but it is quite yellow-based and I feel like there are probably better powder highlighters out there. Still, a welcome addition to my hoard, as it’s the first of its kind!

Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

let’s get Cheeky! See, I can do the pun thing too…no? No? OK…

Right! So that’s the lowdown on this rather lovely palette artefact from Tarte! All in all, I think it was worth hacking our way through miles of hostile jungle – the packaging is good fun, and great if you’re a collector, the eyeshadows are nice quality, and purple, and I enjoyed having my first foray into bronzer and highlighter territory. Is this palette going to change your life? Probably not. But it will make it that much more beautiful, and what else can you ask of a makeup product? 😀

Here’s a random look I did with the palette – you can see that the colours really do make a statement on pale skin, as I was working with a veeeeeery light hand here! I wanted a kind of sorceress look, with ‘gilding’ on the lid in the way that you see old gilding on statues; kind of worn and ‘antique’. For comparison, the actual colour of my skin is what you can see in the bottom leftish sort of area of each photo. I took the pictures looking into natural daylight, so my natural, uh, fluorescence makes the bare skin areas quite bright! Do click the picture to enlarge everything if you need more detail 🙂

Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

Gildy. Purply. Sorceressy?


Finally, it occurred to me as I was looking at this palette that the colour scheme reminded me in some ways of both my Tarte MATTEnificent palette (review) and some shades from my Urban Decay Naked 2 palette (review). I thought I’d swatch them together for comparison, and although you can see that there are some similarities, I think there are more than enough differences to warrant owning all 3 palettes (*shifty eyes*). 😉

Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

Palettes! Can anyone say ‘addiction to cool toned purply things?’


Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

Comparison of some of the light shades that looked similar to my eye in the pan.


Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eyeshadow Palette Swatches Review and Look

…aaaand the dark shades!


*Phew!* Thank you so much for sticking with me through this long jungle temple raid of a review 😉 I want to mention here that this palette swatches up quite differently on different skintones (well, I think so anyway), and I wanted to highlight some lovely reviews and gorgeous looks that others have done of this palette – might help you decide if you’re not a vampire like this rogue! The beautiful Izzie at Izzique has you covered with a *gorgeous* eye look to boot, and as always you can’t go past Christine of Temptalia’s experience and staggering dupe powers. 😀


What do you think, fellow adventurers? Do you like Tarte’s stuff? Do you also have a crippling addiction to purple things? Who do you think has the best packaging?

The practicalities: The Tarte Rainforest After Dark Eye and Cheek Palette costs US$38 for 0.7 oz / 20 g of total stuff,  is limited edition, and may be acquired from or (These links aren’t affiliate, just here for your convenience!). If you are a Rogue of Middle Earth, sadly Tarte requires a US billing address, so you will need to use Ship It To, or hijack a charming US friend to buy it and ship it to you. I did the latter! ❤ ❤ you, Jaa!

Until next time, fellow adventurers, don’t forget to check for traps!


I am an adventuring rogue, not a mercenary for hire, and as such, all opinions expressed here are my own, based on a genuine fondness for/interest in this product. If you have any queries or suggestions, please do not hesitate to pin your parchment to the board (contact me) at thepaintedrogue [at] gmail [dot] com., or use the contact form provided! All images and text on this blog are the property of The Painted Rogue unless otherwise stated. If you nick off with any of it, be prepared to find that your morning hot beverage tastes a little…different than usual. Didn’t the rogue say something the other day about that new poison that makes your innear ear itch maddeningly for the rest of your life? I think she did…


42 thoughts on “The Nocturnal Rogue: Adventuring with Tarte’s Rainforest After Dark Eye and Cheek Palette!

  1. Hey Syl, whoa this is such a pretty one! The eyeshadows look exactly like the shades I want to smear all over my lids, if you catch my drift 😉 I love the look you came up with! Subtly purply is the way to go!


    • Hehe 😀 Thanks, Sunny! I’m so pleased with this palette – I was super excited when I first saw the promo stuff, and it hasn’t disappointed! I keep meaning to try it with LM Amethyst… 😉


  2. Tarte is my favorite brand!!! I just ordered this palette along with some other goodies from Tarte this past weekend. I am excited!!! They had a 30% off Friend and Family sale and when I saw that it was all over!!! 😄😄😉. I have a lot of Tarte stuff but I said what you said above, it is different than my other palettes! 😄😄😄 I also love getting packages in the mail!!! It’s like Santa Claus delivering my presents!!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. Love the look you created above! Thanks for the review and swatches!


    • Aww, thanks Carolyn 😉 You know, funny thing: even though I know they’re supposed to be ‘cool’, I always think these palettes swatch a little warm on me! It’s kind of weird. They make truly cool palettes so infrequently that I kind of leap on them when I get the chance, LOL!


  3. Soooo gorgeous! I love the look you made. Very ethereal 🙂 I seriously cannot splurge right now but that would be a beautiful item toown. I love Tarte’s packaging. They sure knew how to tempt us all! I have never tried their shadows but I have many of their other products including one of those Amazonian clay blushes which I love. Thanks for posting swatches and such.


    • It is a beautiful thing just to have (very dangerous with makeup, but at least powder products don’t go off – or at least that’s how I justify it to myself 😛 ). Tarte’s shadows are different to what I’m used to, actually (which is basically UD), but not ‘worse’. You just kind of have to adjust with some of them to, like, a ‘Tarte’ method of application, LOL!

      I leapt on this as soon as I could, and I’ve been wanting to post the swatches ASAP because it’s LE. But at the same time, I did actually want to test it properly! I’m glad you liked the review! ^_^


  4. I love those eye shadows! Exactly what I’d want in a palette! Not all tarte blushes come with a stiff surface actually.. But it does happen with a few.. My Tarte Blissful for example.. I love the eye looks you’ve done! Ans the Park Ave bronze is definitely not like the one I have from before! Mine is shimmery and much darker and would NOT have worked on you if it were here! Lol! 🙂


    • I found the blush thing a little odd – because the sample card of Dollface I have didn’t have that as much as the ones I have in the palettes. I also don’t own any standalone blushes, so it could be a palette thing (somehow).

      Whoa! LOL, I’m glad I got this version of Park Ave Princess indeed! I do agree with Christine though that brands need to be, you know, a little more consistent with stuff like this. If it’s a different bronzer, call it something different – it’ll probably make the palette more attractive to people who already own a bit of Tarte stuff and don’t want repeats. If you’re reformulating Park Ave Princess, say so!


      • Exactly! I am not sure why they would be so lazy as to not come up with a new name for it! I wish i could show you my Pare Ave Princess.. the expresiion you’d have on your face LOL! Its scary even to me.. lets just say that! 😛


  5. It’s disappointing that Park Ave Princess it’s only a little darker than me, and I’m like you I don’t need highlighter but it’s because of my oily skin; however I do like some shine and sparkle on me.

    Have you tried Bobbi Brown’s form of using bronzer? And also use highlighter over the blush?


    • I believe a Bobbi Brown bronzer was used on me by a MUA at one point, but I have no idea which one! T_T It also never occurred to me to mix the face shades… MUST TRY IT! 😀


      • Well I was talking about how they use bronzer for a healthy glow instead of contouring, but you are not alone about forgetting which shade was used on you (even when Bobbi’s bronzer looked really natural on me)

        I’m glad that I gave you the idea of mixing shades.


      • It was the healthy glow she used it for. I think the foundation I had at the time was a tiny bit too pink as well, so she was evening me out, as well as giving a bit of glow. It was a very subtle bronzer – from the photos you’d never say I was wearing one!

        *mixmixmix* 😀


    • I think it depends a bit more on the skin around your eye… as I mentioned, these colours can stray quickly into ‘bruise’ terrirotry if you’re not careful (and a vampire like me), and I imagine there are some undertones that just really don’t agree with them. As for eye colour, well…I stopped paying attention to that long ago, LOL, as I read one of the ‘guides’ and blue eyes basically got ‘bronze’ and that was it, while brown eyes got all the colours I wanted (blue, green, purple, etc). 😀


  6. I love me some plums, but I have to admit that the thing I love most about this is the way it looks. I adore the packaging. I love the layout. Always a pleasure to read your reviews.


    • Awwn, thanks Kate! ❤ I know what you mean about this palette – I kind of hat to have it just when I saw the promo pic, and then when I fully registered that it had purple shadows I was like BONUS! 😀


  7. Yesss. I love the tones in this palette, but I could never let myself buy it — for some reason I HATE circular palettes, and they always end up wasting away at the back of my drawer. Even ones that can create eye looks this pretty 😦


    • Oh no! 😦 I agree it doesn’t *quite* stack as well with my other stackable things, but I have a weird fondness for circular mirrors. Fact. I was actuallly more excited about the mirror when I opened this palette and saw how big it was and how round, than I was about the contents. Yes, I am weird. I think it might be because my mother had a circular vanity mirror when I was a child 🙂


  8. Ahhhh, Syl, you’re making me go nuts! I have this palette waiting back home for me to play with. Now your review has me wishing my vacation would end so I can get back to it! 😛


      • I know, right? BLEARHGARGHARGH.

        Incidentally, Park Ave. Princess doesn’t show up on me. It’s literally like the same shade as my skin! Soooo…. I use it as a transition shade on mah eyes 😛 How does it work on you as a bronzer?


  9. Hey Syl! This is your first highlighter and bronzer??!! Are you being serious right now??!! HOW?! LOL!

    This post was so much fun to read! I really did feel like I was traveling through the jungle with you and your little friends hehe. It still makes me so sad that I can’t get past the snake design on the front because I really love the colors of the products inside! Oh well!

    I love the eye look you came up with! Very soft and feminine! Plum Away With Me is such a pretty shade and pulls everything together beautifully.

    Thank you for the shoutout, too! I’m always happy to help! 🙂


    • Yep! 😀 I am a bronzer virgin (or was), LOL! Mostly because I’ve always been scard of bronzer making me look dirty/shiny orange/fake tanned. Although I am always harping on it, I’m quite happy with my vampire-ness and have never tried to tan either naturally or with fake tanner – I guess I kind of lumped bronzer in with those!

      I’m glad you liked the post and the look 🙂 Gotta have some jungle adventures! I’m tempted to write some actual little stories about the adventurers for the blog, but I’m not sure if people would really be interested, LOL!

      Heh, I wasn’t sure whether you wanted your assistance advertised, so I kind of stuck you down in the bottom of the post. If you don’t mind it being broadcast, then I’d give you much higher billing! (with even more hearts). 😉


      • Yes to the stories!! I probably won’t understand a whole lot but it sounds like it would be a fun read! 😀

        You are not obligated to mention about me. In fact, I wasn’t expecting to see my name at all and I wouldn’t be offended if you didn’t! I’m just so glad to be able to help my fellow scientist!!! ;D


  10. Up to No Gold is such a pretty color! The packaging and that gold shade make me want to buy it. And thanks for the links to other bloggers who’ve also reviewed the palette. It helps to see what the colors look like on someone with a similar skin tone.


    • I’m kind of a sucker for buttery gold eyeshadows 😉 My favourite shade in the Naked 2 palette is Half Baked!

      No problem for the links – I find how eyeshadows look to be particularly sensitive to skintone, (more so than lipstick, say) and I can only give the ‘extreme vampire’ perspective myself, LOL!


  11. Pingback: Sunday Link Love, Volume #197 | JumpSeek

  12. Pingback: The Perfect Purple Treasure: HG Goodies with Laura Mercier Amethyst and African Violet! | The Painted Rogue

  13. Pingback: Beauty and the Geek Go To Wonderland…with Alice and the Cheshire Cat | The Painted Rogue

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s